Common Challenges of Probate
Throughout the probate process, there may be challenges determining the validity of the will or disputes that arise over the distribution of assets. There are a number of different reasons why an heir or beneficiary may want to contest a will, including:
A common claim for contesting a will is that the testator (the person who created the will) was put under immense pressure to alter their will in a particular way that didn’t reflect their true intentions. Undue influence might be suspected if there is one person who disproportionately benefits from the will, if the testator is vulnerable due to age or illness, or if there were significant changes to the will unusually leaning in a beneficiary’s favor.
For example, a beneficiary may attempt to manipulate a testator who is suffering from cognitive decline or a weakened mental state into changing their will. More often than not, the person pressuring a testator into changing their will is someone close, like a caregiver, friend, or even a family member.
Proving undue influence can be difficult, as it requires demonstrating that the person influencing the testator held a position of power and used it to manipulate them into changing their true intentions. A most common way to prove undue influence is by providing evidence that the influence isolated the testator from other family members. Restricting access to the testator is a popular tactic by those attempting to sway their decisions.
This is one of the most common reasons for contesting a will. If the testator lacked the mental awareness or capacity to understand the implications of their will, one might claim a lack of capacity. It is important that the testator fully understands their decisions and the implications that follow. They should fully understand the value of the assets they own, know who their beneficiaries are, and understand how they plan to distribute those assets.
If the testator is suffering from a mental disorder such as dementia or any other cognitive impairment at the time of drafting or creating the will, beneficiaries may call their mental capacity into question and ask that the will be invalidated.
The party that is contesting the will based on the grounds of a lack of capacity will need to provide medical records, witness testimonies, and any other documentation as evidence that the testator was not of sound mind when creating or updating their will. Proving a lack of mental capacity may even require expert testimony from a healthcare provider or mental health professional.
In some cases, a will may be contested if the testator was deceived into signing their will. Similarly to undue influence, someone may intentionally mislead the testator or misrepresent the facts in order to alter the terms of the will. For example, if a beneficiary provides false information or fails to provide important information that influences the testator’s decisions, it may be grounds for fraud. A forged signature on the will would also be considered fraud. Fraud is a serious accusation, and proving it can often be difficult. It may require witness testimonies and even handwriting analysis.
Fraud claims may also be made if the testator was tricked or manipulated into signing the will. For instance, if the testator was under the assumption that they were signing a different document, it could invalidate the will. Though not as common, fraud can also involve situations where a will was fabricated entirely.
In Colorado, a will must be signed by the testator, it must be witnessed and signed by at least two other parties, and it must be properly notarized if necessary. A will may be contested if it does not meet these requirements for proper execution. In cases where a will is not properly notarized or lacks the required signatures, the court may determine the will to be invalid. Contesting a will based on improper execution involves reviewing the documentation and identifying any deviations from Colorado’s legal standards for will creation.
If it is discovered that the testator revoked their will before passing, the will may be contested. This may happen if the testator created a new will aimed at replacing an existing one, physically destroyed an existing will, or made a written statement revoking the will altogether. Once a will is revoked, it is no longer considered legally valid. In instances where family members or beneficiaries discover another will that contradicts the terms of the original will, disputes may arise over which document should take precedence and be upheld.
- Mistakes or Inconsistent Wills
If the testator made a mistake or was under misapprehension about the facts, the will may be contested. Beneficiaries may also contest if there are multiple existing wills with conflicting terms. Typically, in these cases, the most recently drafted will take precedence over the others.
Mistakes in the language, ambiguities about asset distribution, or misinterpretations of the testator’s wishes are all examples of inconsistencies that may result in legal challenges and delay the probate process. In these situations, the court will be responsible for interpreting the will and determining the testator’s true intentions. This helps ensure a fair and proper distribution of assets.
In order to contest a will, the contestant is obligated to file a formal objection with the Denver Probate Court. This needs to be done before the court has approved the probate. The contestant will need to provide solid evidence for their case and be able to prove that either a mistake was made by the testator or that they were unfit to sign and draft their will. Once the court considers the arguments from both sides of the dispute, they will decide whether or not the will is valid or should be upheld.
Who Can Contest a Will in Colorado?
Regardless of the reason for wanting to contest, only certain individuals are able to challenge a will in court. Only those who stand to benefit from the will have the legal standing to contest. This includes heirs, beneficiaries specifically named in the will, and those who would inherit property under intestate succession if no will exists. Individuals interested in contesting a will must have a valid reason for doing so (lack of mental capacity, undue influence, fraud, improper execution, revocation, or mistakes). Courts are unlikely to even consider a will contest unless there is substantial evidence to support it.
Whether you are tasked with handling the administration of an estate or you are interested in contesting the will, we recommend consulting with a professional probate lawyer. The trusted team of Denver probate attorneys at Evans Case are able to provide top-tier legal assistance that will ensure fair distribution and effective management of your estate. We understand that this is a tough and often complicated process. Do not let the uncertainties and challenges of the probate process overwhelm you. Call Evans Case today to see how we can assist you with your estate.
For all of your Denver estate planning needs, Evans Case is the team that you can trust. With over 100 years of combined experience serving the Denver area, our attorneys understand the needs and challenges faced by Denver families. For a team that truly understands your needs, call Evans Case today and see how we can help make a difference.
Contact Evans Case Today to Speak With a Trusted Probate Attorney
Evans Case has years of experience with probate litigation. The probate process is one that requires constant communication, attention to detail, and careful planning. There are a number of different factors that affect the outcomes and the types of probate that you may pursue. That is why it is beyond helpful to have an experienced probate attorney by your side during the probate process.
We can provide you with expert legal support, invaluable advice about your estate, and most importantly, peace of mind that your estate will be administered with the utmost care and professionalism. If you are dealing with probate or any estate-related issues, do not hesitate to contact our team of Denver probate attorneys today and see how we can make a difference. We want to make sure that the probate process is as smooth and painless as it can possibly be. Don’t wait. Call Evans Case today to speak with one of our Denver probate attorneys.